Toxic friendships: Setting boundaries and knowing when to step away

Two people hugging, from the point of view of behind the second person. The first person, face over the second person's shoulder and arm around them, is screwing their face to the side to suggest unease or suspicion.

Could you be in a toxic friendship, but not sure how to end it?

Lee* and I became friends through work. I’m old enough to be Lee’s mother and soon, I was filling a mum-sized hole in their life. Lee’s relationship with their own mother was fraught and I became the one they turned to for love, reassurance and support.

In hindsight, Lee played on my childlessness by redirecting my maternal instincts. During the pandemic, Lee was made redundant and struggled to hold down a stable job. Their mental health suffered, they moved into social housing after falling out with relatives, they were barely getting by on Universal Credit. It was tough. I was sympathetic and generous with my time and cash. Perhaps the first warning signs.

“Healthy relationships should feel balanced and reciprocal – a place where we can be ourselves, where we can ask for help, and where we feel supported,” says counsellor, Georgina Sturmer, MBACP. “It’s natural for the balance to shift at different times. But overall, when we reflect on the characteristics of our relationship, there’s a hope that it feels like a fun, warm, secure and comforting place.”

When a relationship stops feeling safe, Dr Sham Singh, a psychiatrist at the holistic WINIT clinic in California, says the implications for your mental and physical health are serious. “The consequences include the destruction of self-confidence, constantly damaging and questioning one’s capabilities and sense of self-worth.

“Many people experience increased levels of stress, anxiety, and depression, which may further manifest itself in physical symptoms – sleep disorders, headaches and chronic tiredness from an emotional burden,” Dr Singh continues. “With time, the poisonous dynamics will alienate you from other nurturing relationships, and make getting help or putting perspective on what is happening even more difficult.”

Red flags and setting boundariesA red flag on a blue sky

There was no real balance in the relationship I had with Lee. Sturmer poses the questions I should have asked myself: “Do we feel like a secure adult in the relationship? Or are we being drawn into other roles? Are we becoming a parent or a child in comparison to the other person? Or perhaps we are feeling like a victim or a rescuer.”

Doubts about our relationship that had bubbled away boiled to the surface when mutual friends got in touch with me. Lee had been borrowing money from all of us, telling variations of invented stories to elicit sympathy. Lee could always afford to go to the pub, drinking away the money we lent in good faith. But any conversation about booze was always shut down: “I’m not an alcoholic! How dare you suggest that!”

Their relationship with the truth was casual – Lee’s father is alive and well, but they had told people he was dead. Once, Lee told me their mother had taken her own life, but this was untrue. The explanation for this lie was that their grandmother told them when she was confused.

In the meantime, Lee was putting my name on forms as next-of-kin. I found myself making frequent interventions on their behalf to the housing association for repairs, to the energy company for a smart meter, to the GP to speed up appointments, to the local NHS trust when a mental health assessment went awry…

There were no boundaries in my relationship with Lee, even if I didn’t see it at the time.

“It can be hard to have sufficient perspective to really see what’s going on, but once we have understood that our relationship has become toxic, then it’s useful to recognise what kind of boundaries we need,” says Sturmer.

“We might need to consider external boundaries, offering the other person less time or space, or it might be about internal boundaries. This is more about how we feel on the inside, and the impact that the other person’s words or actions have on our sense of self.”

Dr Singh offers advice on boundaries that I could have used back in 2020. “Setting boundaries with a toxic person requires clarity, yet simultaneously, consistency.”

“It is important to clearly state which behaviours are unacceptable and to convey these limits in an assertive way – be firm, even when the toxic person tries to test or violate those boundaries,” he says. “Another valuable strategy involves you disengaging from their manipulative or guilt-tripping attempts. Learn to say no without going into much explanation, create physical or emotional distance and seek support from trusted friends, family members, or a therapist as a strategy toward maintaining your boundaries.”

Knowing when to end the relationship

Whether the toxic relationship is with a family member or a friend, sometimes calling time is the best solution, even if it’s painful or difficult. Stumer says that signs that it is time to cut ties include when the relationship is “leading us into unhealthy behaviours, leaving us feeling stressed, drained or exhausted, or when we are feeling insecure or unstable within a relationship, questioning whether we can trust the other person.”

For me, it was a combination of stress, exhaustion and broken trust. The final straw came on holiday. Lee texted me for vet bill money for their dermatitis-addled dog while I was at airport security. I replied that I had to put my phone away as my bag was being searched and I wasn’t going to ping cash on unsecured Wi-Fi. Lee sent a barrage of texts about how it would be perfectly safe to send the cash from my banking app. I sent a curt message saying I didn’t appreciate being harassed for money, turned my phone off and got on the plane.

I confessed what was going on to one of my friends on the holiday. Immediately, she told me the relationship was toxic. It was uncomfortable to hear, but she was right.

Phone reception on holiday was poor, but a mournful message got through. “I suppose it’s a hard no on the vet money,” as if I was a heartless puppy killer. Over lunch at a cafe with Wi-Fi, I received a message from a mutual friend. The week before, Lee asked a few of us for taxi money, claiming they’d lost a return train ticket after making a police report about a family dispute. It turns out they’d spent the day in court on assault charges after being charged eight months earlier. Our mutual friend sent me a screenshot. It was a report on the court hearing from the local paper.

How to cut ties

It was lie of such immense proportions – and one that Lee had managed to sustain for almost a year – that I knew it was time to cut ties. So many things suddenly made sense. When I suggested they look into making a fresh start with a job abroad, Lee claimed to have suddenly developed a fear of flying. But the reality was that moving to another country is difficult with a criminal charge hanging over your head.

“The serious consideration for cutting ties should be made when setting boundaries cannot help your mental and physical wellbeing in that toxic relationship,” says Dr Singh. “If the person repeatedly violates your limits, manipulates you or triggers intense emotional distress, it may be time to end the relationship.”

“Most importantly, though, it is time to walk away when such abuse escalates or if there’s a threat against your safety – when you feel this relationship actually stops you from growing and being happy, that is a sure sign it is time to break free.”

Stumer offers practical advice about how to cut ties with someone.

“Your communication should be firm, without going into long discussions and explanations, as those would most definitely invite further manipulative attempts,” Dr Singh says.

He advises blocking or limiting contact, establishing firm boundaries for future relationships and surrounding yourself with “supportive people who actively protect your mental health.”

“Therapy is definitely an option in being able to work through those feelings and cement this decision a little more. Practice self-care and rebuild self-esteem and personal empowerment with the termination of that relationship.”

When I sent Lee a message explaining why I had to cut them off, they lied about why they lied. “I didn’t want to bother you with it when you’d been unwell.” Except Lee was more than happy for me to make interventions on their behalf whenever adulting got a bit too hard, even while I was going through a Christmas cancer scare.

Since cutting ties, I have an overwhelming feeling of freedom. I have more time. I’m in a new era of productivity. I don’t panic when my phone rings. I hope Lee gets much-needed help, but my trust has gone, and I can’t be the mother figure anymore.

 

* Name and some details changed to protect identities.

Read all about it

Silver footer with glowing purple - link to home page www.silvermagazine.co.uk

LINKY-POOS

Just so you know – as if you didn’t – sometimes if you click on a link or buy something that you’ve seen on Silver, we may make a little commission. We don’t allow any old links here though. Read why you should trust us

About Georgia Lewis
In a career that has spanned Australia, the Middle East and the UK, Georgia has written about all sorts of things, including sex, cars, food, oil and gas, insurance, fashion, travel, workplace safety, health, religious affairs, glass and glazing... When she's not writing words for fun and profit, she can usually be found with a glass of something French and red in her hand.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published.


*


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.